Automatic follow-ups: your setter doesn't let a conversation die
A lead comments, you reply, they say "yes send it", you send it — and then silence. That silence is not usually a no. People get distracted mid-thread far more often than they decide against you.
Your setter follows up on its own. You don't switch it on and you don't build anything: it runs on every conversation the AI is handling.
01How it works
If a lead goes quiet, your setter reaches back out up to three times:
- about 4 hours after their last message
- again about 13 hours in
- one last time around 22 hours in
After the third, it stops and marks the conversation stale. That's deliberate. Three attempts inside a day is persistence; a fourth is the thing that gets you reported and blocked.
Every nudge is written fresh for that specific conversation. It references what they actually said, so it reads like you remembered them, not like a reminder fired.
02Why it stops at roughly a day
Instagram only lets a business send freeform messages for about 24 hours after someone's last reply. Once that window shuts, the message simply doesn't deliver.
So the whole sequence is built to finish inside it. That is the reason the three nudges land closer together than you might expect. Spreading them across three days would feel more relaxed and two of the three would never arrive.
If a lead replies at any point, the ladder resets and your setter goes back to having a normal conversation.
03Setting your own timing
The default spacing suits most accounts. If yours needs something different, three settings on the Automations tab of AI Setup change it per profile.
First follow-up (minutes) is how long a lead stays quiet before the first nudge. Gap between follow-ups (minutes) is the space between each one after that. Leave either blank to keep the default.
Both have a floor of 15 minutes. The follow-up cycle runs every few minutes, so a smaller number would be a promise we cannot keep, and we would rather round it up than pretend.
Follow-ups per day is the one that stops a fast cadence turning into hammering. Set it to 2 and a lead gets at most two nudges in your day, however short the gaps are. The day is your day, not UTC, so an evening send does not quietly reset the count. Leave it blank for no daily limit. Either way nobody ever gets more than three in total.
A common setup for high-intent DMs: first follow-up 45 minutes, gap 45 minutes, two per day. A hot lead who goes quiet hears from you twice within a couple of hours and then not again that day.
04Quiet hours
Nudges hold overnight and go out in the morning. A 3am "still interested?" reads like a bot no matter how well written it is.
05What doesn't get followed up
timing, and two systems messaging one person is worse than either alone.
webinar or live call, your setter sends a day-of reminder instead of nudging. That's the better message: "it's tonight, here's the link" beats "you still interested?".
- Anyone who booked. The conversation is over and it worked.
- Anyone who said no or asked to be left alone.
- Leads inside a running flow. The flow owns the
- Leads invited to a live session. If your conversion goal is a scheduled
For every other goal — your website, a free training, a booking link, a trial — the follow-up ladder runs.
06Getting more out of it
The nudges are only as good as what your setter knows. If they feel thin, the fix is almost always in AI Config:
unspoken objection, and a nudge that names it outperforms one that asks "thoughts?".
gives someone a reason to re-engage. One that just repeats the ask doesn't.
- Fill in objection handling. Most quiet leads went quiet because of an
- Keep your offer description concrete. A follow-up that adds a new detail
See Setting up your AI.
